How Climbing Changes Your Finger Bones: A 10-Year Follow-Up Study
What happens to your finger bones after decades of climbing? A unique study followed elite male sport climbers for 10 years, using radiological imaging to track bone changes over time. The findings reveal fascinating adaptations - and some concerns.
Study Design
Researchers performed detailed X-ray imaging of elite climbers' fingers at two time points, 10 years apart. They measured cortical bone thickness (the dense outer layer of bone), presence of osteophytes (bone spurs at joint margins), and signs of osteoarthritis.
The climbers averaged over 20 years of climbing experience at the initial measurement.
Key Findings
Cortical Bone Thickness Increased
Over the 10-year period, the dense outer layer of finger bones became significantly thicker. This represents positive adaptation - the bones literally got stronger in response to climbing loads.
The increase was most pronounced in the middle phalanges (the middle bones of the fingers), which experience the highest loads during climbing grips.
Osteophyte Formation Also Increased
While cortical bone thickening is beneficial, the study also found increased formation of osteophytes (bone spurs) at joint margins.
Osteophytes are typically associated with joint stress and can be precursors to or signs of osteoarthritis.
Osteoarthritis Signs
Some climbers showed progression of osteoarthritis signs over the 10-year period. The PIP joints (proximal interphalangeal - the middle joints of your fingers) were most commonly affected.
Understanding the Trade-Off
The Positive Adaptation
Thicker cortical bone means stronger fingers, greater resistance to fracture, better load distribution, and adaptation to climbing demands.
This is similar to how bones in the dominant arm of tennis players become denser - mechanical loading drives bone strengthening.
The Concerning Adaptation
Osteophyte formation and osteoarthritis progression represent wear and tear. While some degree may be normal for any high-use activity, accelerated degeneration could limit climbing longevity.
What Drives These Changes?
Mechanical Loading
The repetitive, high-force contractions of climbing create mechanical stress that stimulates bone adaptation. The half-crimp and full-crimp positions create particularly high loads on finger joints.
Time Under Tension
Years of climbing accumulate significant loading time. Elite climbers in this study had climbed extensively for two decades or more.
Grip Type
Previous research suggests that crimp grips create higher joint stress than open-hand positions. Grip selection over a climbing career may influence joint health.
Practical Implications
For Current Climbers
Consider grip diversity - using open-hand grips when possible reduces joint stress compared to aggressive crimping. Pay attention to joint pain or stiffness as early warning signs. Include rest days to allow tissue recovery.
For Younger Climbers
Build finger strength progressively over years. Don't rush to maximum crimp loading. Develop open-hand strength alongside crimp strength.
For Masters Athletes
Monitor joint health with regular self-assessment. Consider reducing full-crimp volume if experiencing joint symptoms. Maintain climbing through grip adaptation rather than pushing through pain.
Comparison to Non-Climbers
The study focused on changes within climbers over time, not direct comparison to non-climbers. However, previous research shows climbers develop notably different bone structure in their fingers compared to non-climbing populations.
The key question is whether the beneficial adaptations (stronger bones) outweigh the concerning adaptations (joint wear) for long-term hand function.
Study Limitations
Elite Male Climbers Only
Results may not directly apply to recreational climbers, female climbers, or those who climb less intensively.
Radiological Signs vs. Symptoms
X-ray findings don't always correlate with pain or functional limitations. Some climbers with radiological changes may have no symptoms.
Self-Selected Population
Climbers who stopped due to hand problems weren't included. This may underestimate actual rates of concerning changes.
Long-Term Perspective
This study provides valuable long-term data that's rare in climbing research. The message is nuanced:
On one hand, climbing creates genuinely beneficial bone adaptations. Stronger cortical bone is a positive outcome of training.
On the other hand, cumulative joint stress can lead to degenerative changes. Managing this trade-off through technique, training load, and grip selection matters for climbing longevity.
Recommendations
- Monitor Your Hands - Pay attention to joint stiffness, swelling, or persistent pain
- Vary Your Grips - Don't rely exclusively on full crimps
- Progress Gradually - Build capacity over years, not months
- Prioritize Recovery - Give joints time to adapt between hard sessions
- Seek Evaluation - If symptoms develop, get professional assessment early
Based on: Pastor T, Frohlich S, Pastor T, Sporri J and Schweizer A (2022) Cortical Bone Thickness, Base Osteophyte Occurrence and Radiological Signs of Osteoarthritis in the Fingers of Male Elite Sport Climbers: A Cross-Sectional 10-Year Follow-Up Study. Frontiers in Sports and Active Living